However, it seems that no one company has a formula for ultimate success. There are some hugely profitable matches and then some that just don't sell at all and there is no rhyme or reason for it.....
I am in the circuit since almost 20 years as an amateur, participant/wrestler and -for a short time - producer and I can tell you this : ask 100 guys about what they like and dislike and you will get 100 different answers

Wrestling is a so wide subject and it involves so many things which, apparently, have nothing to do at first with the sport that it is just impossible to satisfy everyone.
My advice is..don't look to satisfy everyone wishes. Be yourself, find your own style and work with talented wrestlers or with hot newcomers that you had train seriously before. You'll see. there will be plenty f people who will answer positively if you do quality and not fake wrestling with blondes models

.
Of course, if you make straight submission wrestling, you won't have the catfight addicts. You decide to do erotic wrestling? Ok..maybe the sub style purists won't answer.
Now I notice there are some cultural differences between the fans. For instance, it seems the French just love catfights. On the other hand, the Americans were always attracted by the pro style more than by anything else...it seems to change now and they are turning more erotic...
The Britishs, as far as I know, love matches ending by a pin rather than by a submission. That would be interesting to explore.